The Tragic Story Of Prince John, AKA The Forgotten Prince

The Royal Family has long been known as one of the most secretive families on the planet, but what if there is even more to them than anyone ever realized? For generations, that was the case. Nowadays, news spreads like wildfire when a member of the family welcomes a new addition.

However, the tragic story of Prince John, aka the Forgotten Prince, goes to show how some additions were much easier to hide away from the world than others. The question is: why was the Royal Family so determined to keep his existence hidden from the world?

It looked as though Prince John had everything he needed to thrive

Being born to the Prince and Princess of Wales - George and Mary - meant that John’s life was meant to be a step above most others across the world. After all, when he arrived into the world on July 12, 1905, John was sixth in line to the British throne and had everything around him to succeed in life.

Sadly, it would turn out that couldn’t be further from the truth. Plenty of factors would eventually lead John down a path that was completely out of his control and made his life more difficult than most people in the Royal Family knew how to deal with. Some now believe that John’s life was doomed from the very beginning.

The name John has long been associated with bad luck among the Royal Family

Of course, like most other families, one of the first things George and Mary had to do was think of a name for their little one. For generations, it’s been traditional in the Royal Family to choose certain names that have been used by former Royals. This was no exception, but many had something to say about their choice.

His Royal Highness Prince John of Wales wasn’t a popular name, as John’s long been a sign of bad luck among the Royals. After all, it’s most associated with King John I, a 13th-century king known as one of the least successful rulers ever. He signed the Magna Carta, but John I is largely seen as a villain.

His christening saw Prince John earn a huge number of godparents

Despite the backlash, it seemed King George V and Queen Mary were determined to stick with the name - kind of. It wasn’t long before people started to affectionately call the new addition Johnnie, perhaps in a bid to steer away from the back luck associated with his name. That didn’t stop him from making his grand debut to the world.

Like everyone else in the Royal Family, Prince John was christened on August 3, 1905, in the parish church at Sandringham. John was also given several godparents, many of them members of his family or other royals, such as King Carlos I of Portugal, Princess Alexander of Teck, and the Duke and Duchess of Sparta, to name just a few.

Like most other royals, Prince John was raised by a nanny for his entire childhood

For the first few years of his life, everything seemed so normal for Prince John and the rest of his family. He was adored by both of his parents and had five siblings to play with at all times. Plus, Johnnie was lucky enough to live and grow up on the family’s 20,000-acre Sandringham estate.

However, there were plenty of things that were different about Johnnie’s childhood than most other children. For one, he was mostly raised by his nanny, a woman called Charlotte Bill, most often called Lala. She was the one to take care of Johnnie from the moment she was born, and it wasn’t long before they shared an unbreakable bond.

It didn’t take long for Prince John’s sense of humor to shine through

It didn’t take long for Prince John’s personality to truly shine through. His nanny, Lala, was always there to make the youngster laugh, and it wasn’t long before he was returning the favor to everyone around him. His relative, Princess Alice, once admitted Johnnie shouted, “She kissed Papa, ugly old man!” right after seeing his parents kiss.

It’s also said that during a particularly fancy dinner party, he used his sister’s painting set to dress up as a Native American and continually pestered his grandfather - the king at the time - until he got his attention. The reason? Johnnie wanted to tell him, “There was a caterpillar on your peas,” but “you’ve eaten it now.”

Pulling pranks was all part of the charm that came with Prince John

It turned out that being a little prankster was something that wouldn’t go anywhere anytime soon for Prince John. In fact, it’s said that as the young royal got older, he merely got more adventurous when it came to his pranks. Some of his apparently favorite things to do were to put pins on chairs and glue on door handles.

Following his many pranks, it wasn’t long before Johnnie’s family and those working at the royal estate started calling him The Imp. Sadly, they would eventually learn that something much darker was brewing beneath the surface. Johnnie wasn’t just pulling pranks; it was like he didn’t know how to behave when his family needed him to the most.

Things started to take more of a turn when Prince John turned four years old

It wasn't just his nanny who noticed there was something more to Prince John and his behavior. His father, King George V, was known to be extremely strict with his other children, later admitting all of his children were "obedient, except John." It seemed no matter what anyone did, Johnnie would always march to his own beat.

Finally, when Johnnie turned four years old, something started to change. People began to notice that he was "winsome" and "painfully slow." People believed that he was showing signs of some kind of developmental disorder, but little was known about these conditions at the time. All they knew was Johnnie wasn't behaving as they hoped he would.

Prince John also started to show other repetitive behaviors as he aged

Another thing that worried people about Prince John was the fact that he started showing repetitive behaviors. It was like he had to do the same things over and over again before he could do anything else, and no one knew why. Eventually, people began to realize Johnnie “simply didn’t understand he needed to [behave].”

Even his mother, Queen Mary, tried everything she could to help Johnnie. It’s said that during one conversation, she admitted to her son she “thought you were going to be good during Lent.” It’s said Johnnie simply replied, “And so did I,” but that “no one told me it was going on for so long!”

Modern researchers now believe that Prince John was likely living with autism

Now, it’s believed that Prince John was most likely living with autism, and that’s why he seemed to show certain behaviors. Everything reported about the way he acted could be considered classic indicators in modern times, but there was still so much the world of science and medicine had to learn at the start of the 1900s.

As well as behaving in certain ways, it’s also said that Johnnie would be blunt whenever he spoke, had a regular facial expression, and had a very specific view of the world for such a young boy. While today things like certain therapies can be used to help someone with autism, Johnnie lived long before these were around.

Living with epilepsy only made Prince John’s condition even worse

Living with autism wasn’t the only thing that plagued Johnnie’s life. It turned out the young prince also started having seizures when he was just four years old and was most likely living with epilepsy, too. Sadly, this wasn’t something that was going to get better without treatment, not that the people around Johnnie knew at the time.

His epilepsy only got worse as Johnnie grew older, especially as most of the treatments at the time revolved around herbal cures and other chemicals. With no treatment and no idea what to do to help their son, Johnnie’s health took a major turn for the worst - and those around him were none the wiser.

His many health conditions eventually meant Prince John stopped appearing in public

The Royal Family has always lived lives that are very different from the rest of the world, but there was always the thought that the blood of the family was “purer” than the rest of the nation. However, that was thrown into question when Prince John started showing signs of all these health conditions and ailments.

As a result, it seems Johnnie’s family made some questionable choices. While some claim he was hidden from the public at a young age, it seems it was turning 11 years old that really saw Johnnie step out of the limelight. As well as managing his health, it appeared the Royals wanted to maintain their public image.

Not appearing with his family at events was something Prince John was already used to

It seemed that not appearing alongside his family was nothing new for Prince John. After all, he was almost six years old when his parents were crowned on June 22, 1911. However, Johnnie was noticeably missing from the celebration. At the time, it was said that the event would be too much for Johnnie’s health to handle.

However, critics of the Royal Family had other ideas. They believed that the family was deliberately keeping Johnnie away from the public because they were embarrassed by him and more worried about their image. In their eyes, Johnnie doing something wrong would be highly embarrassing, and he was deemed not “presentable to the outside world.”

Prince John started to disappear from official royal portraits, too

It turned out public outings were the only place where Prince John was missing. From 1913 onward, he didn’t appear in any official photos taken for the Royal Family. In fact, the prince didn’t even appear in the 1918 photo for his parents’ silver wedding anniversary, even though his other siblings were all seemingly present for the occasion.

This is where people start to divide. Some believe George and Mary were embarrassed by Johnnie. Then there are others who think they knew Johnnie wouldn’t have been able to sit still for so long and gave him the option not to attend. Still, there was something strange, as the prince regularly appeared in the family’s personal photos.

People started to forget that Prince John even existed in the first place

Of course, being in their private photos didn’t mean much to the rest of the world. After all, they were just that - private. To those on the outside, it was easy to forget Prince John even existed in the first place. Things only continued to get worse as Johnnie got older, especially when his brother, Prince George, went to school.

In 1912, it was announced he would be going to St. Peter’s Court Preparatory School in Broadstairs. As George was Johnnie’s closest sibling, it was assumed he would follow as soon as he was old enough. However, the following year, The Times reported Johnnie wouldn’t be going to Broadstairs - or any kind of school at all.

His epilepsy continued to get worse, leading Prince John to leave the family home

By the time 1916 rolled around, Prince John had all but disappeared from the rest of the world. It’s believed that his epilepsy had gotten so bad that it was now unsafe for him to be too far away from home, so it appeared that it was easier to leave Johnnie at home in the care of his nanny instead.

Even then, it got to the point that Johnnie needed more help. Eventually, George and Mary settled on sending him to live at Wood Farm, but that might not have been as harsh as it sounded. The young prince wasn’t banished from the house. He was in a different home, but Johnnie was never far from his parents.

Lala soon stepped up as Prince John’s primary caregiver at Wood Farm

The Sandringham Estate covers 20,000 acres, and it’s more than just the main Royal Family home. That’s right; part of the estate includes Wood Farm. In fact, the five-bedroom residence is one one of the more secluded parts of the estate and overlooks the sea, making it the perfect getaway - and an eventual favorite of Queen Elizabeth II.

Living just two miles from his parents meant that Johnnie was never far from his loved ones, and he wasn’t alone. He also lived in his new house with his nanny, Lala, who quickly became his primary caregiver. While Johnnie still had someone close by who loved him, his descent into loneliness really started to snowball.

The people working at Wood Farm became the only people Prince John would see

After the summer of 1916, Prince John was rarely seen around the Sandringham Estate. Sure, he was well looked after in terms of the resources he had and always having more than enough food, but there was one major thing lacking from Johnnie’s life: company. After all, he was almost completely isolated at Wood Farm.

His nanny, Lala, and the other housekeepers became the only people Johnnie would see most days. His parents were the heads of the Royal Family, so they were always incredibly busy with royal duties and public appearances. Plus, his siblings were all at boarding school or in the military, meaning they were no longer around to keep Johnnie company.

The King and Queen ultimately decided there was no point continuing with their son’s education

George and Mary seemingly decided going to school was too much for Prince John to handle, but that didn’t mean he had to miss out on an education altogether. After all, they had access to some of the best tutors in the country. That was until they decided to let them go, too, meaning Johnnie never got a proper education.

It’s said the Royals believed that Johnnie could express himself clearly but was no longer progressing with his grades, so they didn’t see the point in continuing with his education. Instead, the young prince became stuck where he was and didn’t even have classes and lessons to help pass the days he was stuck at Wood Farm.

Not getting an education was nothing new for the Royal Family at the time

Nowadays, it might sound pretty questionable to stop someone’s education just because they aren’t making any more progress. However, this was nothing out of the ordinary at the time. In fact, there was nothing in the rules that said children from the Royal Family had to receive a formal education at all, but that changed with Prince John’s siblings.

It’s reported his older brother, Henry, was the first son of a British monarch to even enroll in school. That’s why it didn’t seem so much of a deal that Johnnie was pulled from school and had his tutors canceled. Sadly, this might have made his health worse. After all, Johnnie was no longer socializing with children his own age.

Prince John needed something to help pass the days, but no one helped

Getting cut off from the rest of the world saw Prince John’s mental health take a major nosedive. Thankfully for the young prince, he always had his nanny, Lala, by his side, and it was said that she cared for Johnnie like one of her own. However, it wasn’t the same as being with his family.

They might have been nice, but the staff working at Wood Farm weren’t children who were there to play with Johnnie. Without any playmates or school to keep him busy, the young prince would often have hours on his hands and be constantly lonely. He needed something to give his day purpose, but no one seemed to help.

His grandmother had a suggestion to help Prince John find something fun to do

The weeks continued to pass, and Prince John was rapidly going downhill. That was until his grandmother, Queen Alexandra, came to visit the young prince and had a suggestion. It’s believed she could see how much Johnnie was hurting and wanted to find a way to help, so she suggested he take up a new hobby.

In fact, the Queen came up with an idea for Johnnie. She suggested he start gardening. While it might have seemed like a strange suggestion for an 11-year-old royal, it turned out to be the best thing that could’ve happened. Johnnie took to the hobby instantly, with it being noted it became “one of the great pleasures” in his life.

Spending time in the garden proved to be just the thing that Prince John needed in his life

His grandmother could see how much Prince John needed a purpose in life, and it wasn’t long before he started visiting Queen Alexandra more and more regularly. She was also living in one of the grand houses at the Sandringham Estate, and she lived here alone, so the Queen appreciated the company as they bonded over gardening.

Particular areas of the garden were set aside for Johnnie to care for under the careful watch of his grandmother. When they were grown and had bloomed, Johnnie even started to collect the flowers and press them to include them with letters to his parents. At last, he had the thing he needed so desperately: something to do.

Prince John’s grandmother realized he needed friends who were his own age

Sadly, like most other things in his life, it wasn’t long before the thrill of falling for gardening started to wear off, and Prince John realized that he was alone once again. He would regularly visit his grandmother and help where he could, and it was Queen Alexandra who realized something had to change soon to help her grandson.

When writing to George and Mary, Queen Alexandra confessed that Johnnie was “very proud of his house but is longing for a companion.” It seemed this was all Mary needed to step up and do something to try and help her son. As much as spending time with his grandmother and nanny was great, he needed friends his own age.

Queen Mary and Lala set about finding the young prince a friend

While it might be easy to wonder how this wasn't something Prince John’s mother thought of immediately, things were very different at the start of the 1900s, especially when it came to the Royal Family. There were still plenty of traditions and unwritten rules they needed to upkeep, and addressing loneliness wasn’t something that was commonly done.

Still, Queen Mary reached out to Lala to look for local children who could be friends with the young prince and keep him company. Thankfully, their plan worked, and it wasn’t long before they had the perfect match. After a lengthy vetting system, they found Winfred Thomas, a girl living on the Sandringham Estate who instantly befriended the prince.

Befriending Winfred Thomas really helped to turn Prince John’s life around

It turned out that Prince John and Winfred Thomas had known each other for years from when they were younger, and it just so happened that she now lived on the same estate as the young prince. Thankfully, it wasn’t long until the pair became best friends, something that really turned Johnnie’s life around once and for all.

With a new best friend by his side, Johnnie actually started to enjoy living at Wood Farm. The pair were often seen doing all kinds of things together, such as working on Johnnie’s garden or hiking around the grounds. Johnnie and Winfred would even take the family carriages and tour around the surrounding area in their spare time.

Prince John also started to prank people and cause mayhem once again

As Prince John started to get more confident, thanks to his new friendship, he also began to make new friends. One of those was Elsie Hollinsworth, but that wasn’t all that happened. It turned out that being around children his own age also saw Johnnie’s prankster side come back out as he learned to have fun with others again.

Elsie later recalled a time when Johnnie used one of the painter’s ladders to climb up the side of the farm. Apparently, everyone started panicking as they were “running around down below,” telling Johnnie “not to fall off.” While everyone else panicked until he came down, Johnnie supposedly found it “very funny” to see people so worried.

The prince’s friends claimed the rumors he was abandoned were far from true

Behind closed doors, it appeared that Prince John was beginning to thrive again. However, to the rest of the world, it seemed the Royal Family was keeping their son hidden from the public to avoid any embarrassment. Still, Johnnie’s friends from the time were later keen to set the record straight once and for all.

For one, they claimed George and Mary were far from absent in their son’s life, and Johnnie spent most days smiling and enjoying himself. It’s said his parents would shower him with love and visit when they could, but that didn’t stop people from talking. After all, George and Mary were about to be pretty busy.

The outbreak of World War I saw Prince John left behind as his parents stepped up their duties

In 1914, the world changed forever. After all, this was the year that World War I began, and it wasn’t long before the Royal Family were thrown into the thick of it. After the outbreak of the war, Prince John rarely saw his parents because they were often busy with royal duties, which didn’t help with the rumors.

As they were the reigning monarchs, George V and Queen Mary were tasked with keeping the morale of the country high and honoring the troops fighting for the nation, so they would travel across the UK and often be gone for weeks at a time. Due to his health, Johnnie was left to stay at Wood Farm.

Prince John could have also been sent to Wood Farm to keep him out of psychiatric facilities

Prince John’s friends also had more to say about what happened to the young royal during his time at Sandringham Estate. They wanted to make it clear that Johnnie was never sent to Wood Farm because his parents were ashamed of him. Instead, they state that George and Mary wanted to protect the young prince.

At the time, many people who were diagnosed with epilepsy were sent to questionable psychiatric facilities as it was deemed as a mental illness and, therefore, treated as one. It’s said the Royals deeply cared about their son and didn’t want Johnnie to end up here, so they kept him locked at Wood Farm for his own protection.

The prince was never removed from the line of succession

This might be more than Prince John’s friends trying to twist the facts to help his parents look better. After all, when he was born, Johnnie was sixth in line to the British throne, and it was something that was never taken away from him. That’s right; his parents could have stepped in and truly erased his existence.

If Johnnie was removed from the line of succession, there’s every chance the world truly would have forgotten that he ever existed at the time. However, keeping him there seemed to argue against the idea that George and Mary were ashamed of their son. Still, that didn’t stop people from questioning many of their decisions regarding the young prince.

Documents appear to show that Prince John was favored over his siblings

Looking into what life was like for Prince John, it appears that things might have been better for the royal than meets the eye. After all, several things suggest that he was treated far better by his parents than any of his siblings. George V was known to be incredibly strict, sometimes offering harsh punishments if his children misbehaved.

However, when it came to Johnnie, he was usually let off and got to relax a lot more than his siblings. Queen Mary is also thought to have favored Johnnie over all of her other children. When it came to his siblings, they seemed to believe he was handed his own home on the estate and an easy ride.

His health only got worse as the years continued to pass

For the most part, it was assumed - and hoped - that as Prince John got older, his conditions would settle down, and he would be able to live more of a normal life. However, that was far from the case. In fact, as he got older and with a lack of medication and treatment, Johnnie’s seizures became more frequent and severe.

Several doctors were called to see if anything could be done, but their various diagnoses and the outlook weren’t looking good. They concluded there was every chance that Johnnie would never make it to adulthood. The hope his parents had held onto for so long was quickly fading as time was running out for Johnnie.

The King and Queen ultimately made the choice to keep Prince John from his siblings

When he was younger, Prince John loved nothing more than spending time and playing with his siblings. However, as he was the youngest, they were all off to school and the military. Plus, Johnnie’s health was rapidly getting worse, which left George V and Queen Mary with a difficult decision. Ultimately, they stopped Johnnie’s siblings from visiting.

According to Johnnie’s nanny, Lala, it was tough for the family to see the young prince when he was so sick, so the monarchs thought it was easier for them to not see him at all. In fact, it’s recorded that the seizures were “getting so bad and coming so often,” which “upsets [Johnnie’s siblings] so much.”

Celebrating with his family became more and more rare for Prince John

Of course, knowing that time was rapidly running out for their son meant there were fewer and fewer times for Prince John to spend with his family. After all, big occasions like the holidays and birthdays only come once a year, and the family began to worry if Johnnie would make it to the next celebration.

Thankfully, things took a positive turn on Christmas Day 1918. Johnnie was given the all-clear to travel to the family home for the holidays. World War I had just ended, and there was plenty to celebrate. Unfortunately for Johnnie’s family, they had no idea that this would be the last time most of them got to see the prince.

Prince John passed away just a few weeks after the Christmas celebrations

Tragically, not long after he celebrated Christmas with his family, Prince John lost his life. That moment came on January 18, 1919, when the young royal was just 13 years old. It’s said that he had suffered a particularly violent seizure and ultimately passed away in his sleep, bringing an end to his suffering after so many years.

In one way, Johnnie’s family was comforted to know that he no longer had to suffer. Still, this was little comfort. Lala was particularly devastated by losing the young prince. It’s said that she kept a photograph of the prince on her mantlepiece for the rest of her life alongside a note that read “Nanny, I love you” from Johnnie.

George V and Queen Mary were left to grieve the loss of their young son

Losing someone so suddenly can really take a toll on a family. Even though they knew they didn’t have long left with Prince John, his passing still came as a tragic surprise to his parents. By the time he passed away, Johnnie was believed to be suffering greatly from his seizures and other health issues.

Queen Mary later wrote in her diary that it was a “great shock” to lose her son, but it also came as “a great relief.” According to her own notes, Mary “broke the news to George,” and they “motored down to Wood Farm,” where they found a “heartbroken” Lala. For George, his son’s passing was “the greatest mercy possible.”

Prince John’s older brother, Edward, was incredibly callous about his sibling’s passing

Sadly, it seems not everyone was so distraught with the loss of Prince John. His older brother, Edward, was 11 years his senior and never really got to know Johnnie because of the age gap and being kept away from his sibling. Still, many were surprised when Edward decried Johnnie’s passing as “little more than a regrettable nuisance.”

Edward even went as far as saying it was “what we’ve always silently prayed for” as Johnnie was “more of a burden than a blessing,” who was “more of an animal than anything else,” and “only a brother in the flesh and nothing else.” Edward later apologized to his mother for his words, saying he felt “cold hearted and unsympathetic.”

Edward’s remarks didn’t help convince the public to change their minds about the Royal Family

Although Edward’s letter to his mother has been lost, it’s believed she never replied. It certainly didn’t help with Edward’s reputation, something that never recovered during his time on the throne. Still, it was Edward’s photo albums that eventually saw Prince John’s memory come back to light once more. The twist? He was part of the reason Johnnie was forgotten.

After all, speaking so harshly about the young prince only fuelled rumors that the Royal Family was ashamed of their son and wanted to keep him away from the world, despite the fact others claim that none of that is true. Still, the fact the public had no idea just how sick Johnnie was didn’t help either.

The world only learned about Prince John’s epilepsy once he passed away

Even though he was a part of the Royal Family, the public never had any idea that Prince John was so sick or that he was even living with epilepsy to begin with. In fact, many merely believed that he had been hidden away from the world to protect their image, something that was only made worse by the secrecy.

That was until Johnnie passed away in 1919. Only then did the Daily Mirror report that he had been ill, a secret that ultimately backfired more than anyone imagined when it came to the remaining Royals. Now, people believed they hated the young prince, and many demanded justice for Johnnie now that he had passed away.

Prince John’s funeral was unlike other royal funerals of their kind at the time

Royal protocol at the time meant that Prince John’s funeral should have been a private matter. However, one thing people quickly learned was that Johnnie never lived by the rules, so his passing was no different. Instead of keeping things between his blood relatives, all of the Sandringham House staff were allowed to attend the funeral.

In fact, every single person who worked on the estate turned out to say goodbye to the young prince. This was especially touching as many of them became the primary caregivers to Johnnie in his later years, especially once he moved to Wood Farm. His grave was piled high with flowers as everyone wanted to honor his memory.

People began to act as though Prince John had never even existed

Even though learning that Prince John had been living with epilepsy and ultimately lost his life was huge news at the time, it wasn’t long before his memory seemingly faded from history. When people reported on George and Mary, they sometimes stated the couple only ever had five children, and many family trees were missing the prince altogether.

Now, it’s hard to know if this was done intentionally or if it was an accident. After all, facts about the time were hard to document as there was no internet around to keep people updated. It could have been a move by someone to erase Johnnie’s memory, but it was something that wouldn’t last.

Various authors have their own theories about why Prince John was hidden from the public

It was two decades after Prince John’s passing that people began to realize those with epilepsy shouldn’t be locked away. However, some authors claim that the Royal Family thought these conditions might flow through their blood, even though royal blood was still considered to be more pure than that of a commoner. To them, this is why Johnnie was hidden.

Others have suggested that Johnnie might have been sent to Wood Farm to try to give him the best atmosphere they could during World War I. Still, there are always people on both sides of the fence. Another author theorizes that the Royals were “frightened and ashamed of John’s illness” and just wanted him to disappear.

Discovering lost family photos brought Prince John’s memory back to life

Even though the world moved on and forgot about Prince John, that all changed in 1998. Two volumes of Edward’s family photographs were found, and Johnnie was thrown back into the limelight. Suddenly, we got more of a look than ever into the young prince’s life, and people wanted to know who was in the pictures.

After all, it’s not every day that you learn about a Forgotten Prince, especially one who lost his life at such an early age. People started digging into Johnnie’s life and history, with more theories and rumors floating around about what really happened. Eventually, the British historical drama ‘The Lost Prince’ was made in 2003 to honor his memory.

Prince John’s legacy is now something that will never be forgotten

For years, Prince John’s life and memory were used as an argument against the British Royal Family. After all, they claimed he was hidden from the world and mistreated by those who were supposed to love him the most. However, others now realize a lot of the rumors have been hugely exaggerated throughout the years.

Whatever the case, it appears that one thing is clear: people merely didn’t know how to give Johnnie the care and medical treatments that he needed. Thankfully, most tales point toward the young prince being loved and adored by his family, even if they couldn’t give him the things he needed to live a long and healthy life.

You May Also Like

Entertainment The Classic Icons Influencing Today's Celebrities Entertainment Hollywood Comebacks That Deserve a Second Look Entertainment Child Stars Who Built Careers on Their Own Terms